Pardon me, folks. I’m sort of thinking out loud here…
I used to set the corporate hardware and software standards for Novell. As part of that job, I had the opportunity to do thorough technical evaluations of nearly every desktop, notebook, and server that came out of Compaq/HP, Dell, IBM, and Toshiba. I tracked industrial design, technology, quality control, and service trends like most guys track sports scores. I can recite chipset minutiae on command.
I’ve done it long enough that, at this point, my skills are almost instinctive. Within seconds of getting my hands on a piece of hardware, I can tell you whether it’s even worth considering. Give me your budget, your level of technical sophistication, what hardware you’ve used in the past, and your current technical requirements and I can probably give you at least two purchasing recommendations that would take your breath away with their exquisite appropriateness.
Between setting corporate standards and making personal recommendations for family, friends, and countless other acquaintances, I’ve helped literally thousands of people find the perfect computer for their lives and jobs. So, why is it that I can’t, for the life of me, decide what computer to buy for myself?
For one thing, I’m so burned out right now that I am almost incapable of making even the most basic of decisions. Just deciding what shoes to wear in the morning makes my brain hurt.
But, beyond that, the problem is that my question isn’t really a technical one. It’s philosophical and financial in nature and it’s one that requires a certain level of clairvoyance.
Since I’ll be leaving my current job next week, I need to purchase a new computer for myself. That’s all I know. Where’s my next paycheck coming from? I don’t know. What is my next job going to be? I don’t know. Am I going to be making a living with this computer, or will it just be my “home machine?” I don’t know. Do I need a notebook for travel? I don’t know.
As I see it, here are my three options (brand names and most technical specs removed as this is a philosophical exercise):
-
Buy a practical, relatively inexpensive, mid-range desktop system.
Rationale: Since I don’t know where my next paycheck is coming from, now is the time to be safe and frugal. I should buy something “adequate” right now with the idea that if I land a decent job I can always turn it into the kids’ machine in a year or so and buy something better.
-
Buy a nice, fast, capacious notebook.
Rationale: If I get any consulting/contract gigs, I’ll need the portability. Besides, even though I’ve always had a desktop computer to go with it, I’ve carried a notebook for the past 12 years. My whole computing life has been based on the idea that I can do my work whenever/wherever I am and I’m a little afraid of giving that up.
For instance, I’m taking my girls to Disneyland this October. If I had a notebook, I could take it along and upload all of the digital photos and video we’ve shot at the end of each day and keep on top of email after the girls have gone down. That kind of freedom means a lot.
A notebook would cost a bit more and the overall performance wouldn’t be spectacular (about even with the mid-range desktop), but I would be using it as a true desktop replacement.
I would also need to decide between the 15” model or 17” model. I’ve carried an older version of the 15” model for almost three years now and I’ve loved it. But for only $400 more I’d get a faster processor and (obviously) a larger, higher-resolution screen. (The higher resolution would be especially nice.)
My only worry about the 17” is that it would be just too darn big. I’m not concerned about the weight. At 6.9 pounds, it’s a marshmallow compared to the 8-pound ThinkPads I carried for years. But at 15.4” x 10.2”, I’m afraid it’d feel like I had a card table strapped to my back.
I’ve never actually been able to pick up a 17” model to ascertain its overall heft. The only local retail store that carries these particular models has them bolted to the counter with a big bar across the keyboard. I asked if they would be willing to unbolt it so I could pick it up and turn it over in my hands and the guy looked at me like I was insane.
“Well, I can tell you how heavy it is,” he said, as he fumbled for a spec sheet.
“I already know how heavy it is. It’s just hard to tell if a notebook is going to be easy to handle if you haven’t actually handled it.”
“Well, I can tell you how thick it is,” he said, as he fumbled for the spec sheet again.
“No, sorry,” I explained. “I already know its size and weight. But knowing those specs isn’t the same as actually holding it in my hands. I mean, when you buy a car, you do your research beforehand and compare the specs of all the various models, but you can’t really tell how a car performs if all you’re allowed to do is look at it on the dealership lot. To get a real feel for the car you need to actually get in and take it for a test drive.”
“Well,” he explained, obviously bored with me, “we never unlock our notebooks, for security purposes.”
“Then I guess I’ll have to go somewhere else, for purchasing purposes…”
-
Buy a gorgeous, fast, dual-proc workstation with a nice, big LCD screen.
Rationale: Now’s the time to take that serverence check and buy the best computer I can possibly afford. Chances are I’ll be earning a living with it (at least to some extent), so I might as well have the best tool for the job.
Besides: portability, schmortability. Part of the problem with being able to take your work anywhere is that you inevitably end up taking it everywhere. In a way, a desktop computer enforces a separation between what you do and who you are. (If such a separation actually exists.)
And if I ever get around to putting my aborted film school experience to work, it’d be ideal for video editing.
My friends Ben and Dan have been steering me toward the gorgeous, fast, dual-proc workstation (mainly because they’ve been trying to push me toward filmmaking as a profession), my brother Chris is leaning toward the 17” notebook, and my wise and frugal sisters have been recommending the mid-range desktop.
Me? I’m leaning toward the 17” notebook, but what do I know…